A guardian is the person you name in your will to take care of your children in the event you die before they turn 18. If the children’s other parent is still alive, that person will have the first right to custody of your children. Most of the time, that is your wish as well. There are circumstances where you don’t want the children’s other parent to have custody – instances of child abuse, the other parent has been absent in the children’s lives or perhaps the other parent is very ill.
In every case, though, you need to choose a person other than the children’s other parent as a back-up guardian so that if you both die together, your children will still be protected from possible family strife as to who will be the guardian.
What is the responsibility of the guardian? You can name one guardian to be the children’s physical guardian, someone with whom they will live full-time, who will rear them until they are legally an adult. You can name a different guardian to have custody of the children’s financial inheritance. If you have written a good estate plan, your children’s inheritance will be in a trust with the person you know to have good financial skills named as the trustee. Sometimes the guardian of the children and their inheritance will be the same person.
You should name only one person as a guardian, with an alternate choice if your first choice won’t or can’t serve in that capacity. If you name a couple (maybe your sister and brother-in-law), there are complications if they disagree about how to raise your children or if they divorce.
How do you decide who will be the guardian of your children? Any persons you select must be at least 18. You want someone who has good feelings about your children and who your children like. The guardian should have the energy to raise your children until adulthood (which sometimes eliminates your parents). Other intangibles include whether the guardian shares your values, both moral and religious, and whether your children would have to move to live with the guardian or can stay in their hometown, close to their friends and the familiar details of their lives. If you don’t have the financial means to raise your children, you want your choice of guardian to have enough money so that it is not a strain on your children or the guardian.
You must talk to your prospective guardians to ensure that they are willing to act as your children’s guardian. Nothing could be worse for you than the situation in which after taking so much time and care to choose someone, that person can’t or won’t take on the responsibilities of acting as a guardian.
You do not have to name the same person to be the guardian of all of your children. It is possible that your children are so different in age or temperament that two or more guardians will work better than one guardian. Or you may have children from different marriages and relatives from one marriage will be willing to be a guardian for only the children from that marriage.
If you feel that the person you have named as the guardian will provide a great home but is not very good at managing his checkbook, then you can name someone else as the financial guardian. If you are going to pick different guardians, you must ensure that they will work together in your children’s best interests.
By naming a guardian and trustee of your children’s inheritance in your will, you are significantly decreasing the possibility that your relatives will be fighting each other over your children. Without a will, a judge gets to decide who your children will live with and who will have control of your assets. Although the judge is supposed to use the standard of “best interests of the child” in making his decision, it is the judge’s idea of your children’s best interests that will decide the issue, not yours. Do you want a total stranger making that decision for you?
Many parents avoid making a will because they can’t decide on a guardian. But, remember that your decision is not written in stone. If you change your mind in two years, or five years, you can always change your will. If you are afraid of hurting a family member’s feelings, then write a letter to him/her explaining why you chose someone else. You first loyalty should be to your children and your decisions must always reflect your desire to bring them up in the way you would yourself.
Choosing a guardian is probably the hardest part of deciding how to write your will. But not deciding is also a decision. It means that you have concluded that a judge who doesn’t know your family can decide better than you can who is a better choice to raise your children. Don’t leave this decision to a total stranger. Talk to family, friends, and an estate planning lawyer about how to make this difficult choice. But remember any decision is better than no decision.