It is obvious to most people that if you have a big estate and you divide it unequally, that your heirs (usually that’s your family) will be mad at you and each other because they were not treated the same. But, even if you don’t have a large estate and the main thing that you have to give to your family is your “stuff,” leaving unequal shares or not giving instructions on how it should be divided, can also cause hard feelings.
What do I mean by “stuff?” Think of your furniture, your jewelry, your Beanie Baby collection, your golf clubs, or your Christmas ornaments. The monetary value of some of the things you own can be minor but who gets them can cause a big fight among the people you love.
I do not advise my clients to make lists of their possessions and include the distribution of these items in their wills. If you originally give your diamond earrings to one daughter but later change your mind and wish to give it to your other daughter or a granddaughter, then you don’t want to have to change your will. Standard wills have a paragraph that gives the personal property to a spouse or to the children in equal shares, with the executor of the will deciding who will get what. If there is a spouse in the picture, there are usually no arguments. But, when it’s the executor who must decide who gets what, and especially when the executor is one of the children, then I see lots of bad feelings among family members that take years to overcome.
If you have definite feelings that one child should have a particular possession, then create a separate letter to be attached to the will, that lists the possession and who should get it. Add to that list all of your other possessions that you have specific people in mind who should inherit them. If you run out of ideas as to who should inherit what, have a family meeting and ask your family if any one is interested in inheriting a specific item. There may be more than one person interested in a particular item, so you may need to do some trading around until there is family harmony. If you don’t feel that you can face a family discussion about this topic, talk to each family member one-on-one. If you explain in your letter, why you are giving certain things to certain people, it usually dispels some of the bad feelings.
You can also give your stuff away while you are alive so that you can see your family enjoying these items while you are alive. Most of us have more than enough stuff that giving away one item to each family member will not leave you with an empty jewelry box or an empty house.
The most important consideration is giving some guidance to your executor on how to divide your stuff and why you are giving these particular things to particular family members. People want to think they are being treated fairly, so if you are not giving in equal shares, make sure everyone knows why.
Please feel free to forward this blog post to your colleagues, listserv members or favorite bloggers. Or if you would like to run it (in whole or in part) in any publication or quote from it, simply include my name and URL: http://www.GronskyLaw.com. No prior permission needed. To inquire about joining my list to receive my blog posts or my availability to speak to your group or write an article for your publication, please email me at RGronsky@Gronskylaw.com. Thank you!